MAKEUP ALL STARS Pre-Submit Look Checklist
A fast final pass that catches the mistakes anonymous voters punish.
Why you need a checklist
In MAKEUP ALL STARS, anonymous voters in a max-10 player lobby decide in a glance. Most losing looks are not “untalented”—they are unfinished, off-theme, or mismatched in hair/lash weight. This checklist is the last filter before submit. Use it with the Theme Idea Board and the timing advice in How to Win.
Run it in the final third of the timer, not after the timer expires in your head. If you never have time left, your pacing is the real bug—fix Free Play with a clock.
The 60-second checklist
1) Theme keyword match
- Say the prompt out loud. Does your look answer the nouns and adjectives?
- If the prompt says soft/romance, did you accidentally build club graphics?
- If it says runway/editorial, is there a clear graphic or fashion idea—not just “more glitter”?
Fail → simplify toward the Themes guide interpretation.
2) Readability at thumbnail distance
- Zoom out mentally: would a voter understand the eye shape and lip story small?
- Muddy brown sockets without a focal point fail this test.
- Tiny details nobody can see waste seconds—boost contrast on the hero feature.
3) Blend and edge audit
- Cheek and lid edges: harsh where you want graphic, soft where you want glam.
- No accidental streaks across temples.
- Skin base still even around the mouth and nostrils.
Technique refresh: Makeup Techniques.
4) Hair and lash harmony
- Hair density matches eye weight.
- Lash length matches liner intensity.
- Color story does not fight the theme (neon hair on “office clean” is a self-own).
If your rarest Boutique piece breaks harmony, unequip it. Pride is not a podium. Spend plan: Boutique and Coins.
5) Facial third balance
- One hero zone (eyes OR lips OR graphic cheek)—supporting cast stays quieter.
- Brows groomed enough to frame, not so loud they steal editorial shapes.
- Lips finished; half-filled lips read as AFK.
6) Device and lighting sanity
- On mobile: check that wings are symmetric enough; fix the worse side first.
- On desktop: do not over-zoom into pores you will never show voters.
- Avoid last-second color swaps that break the whole story.
7) Submit and vote plan
- Submit with enough time to vote carefully.
- Vote theme fit + finish quality, not chat popularity.
- Note one fix for next round in your head (blend, theme, or hair).
Extended checklist for Free Play reviews
Use this longer pass after practice sessions—not mid-live round:
- Screenshot and compare to your tier list target style
- Ask: would Soft Glam or Editorial have fit better?
- Time your phases: skin %, eyes %, lashes/hair %, polish %
- Rebuild once with fewer products mentally—restraint training
- Retry the same theme with an opposite bucket from the Idea Board
Common fail tags (name them)
Labeling mistakes makes them fixable:
- OFF-THEME — pretty but wrong prompt
- MUD — unblended transitions
- HALF — unfinished lip/lash/hair
- CLASH — hair/lash vs face weight
- NOISE — too many accents
- LATE — no time to self-audit
Track which tag costs you the most podiums across a week. That tag tells you which guide to reread on the Guides Hub.
Example live pacing with checklist
Assume a round long enough to paint thoughtfully (exact timers can vary with updates—adapt):
- 0–10%: theme decode + Idea Board pick
- 10–40%: skin + eyes
- 40–65%: cheeks, lips, brows
- 65–80%: hair/lashes
- 80–90%: checklist
- 90–100%: micro-fixes + submit + vote
If eyes always eat 70% of your time, preset a simpler eye for soft themes and save complex graphics for editorial weeks.
After Boutique or theme updates
When Updates announce new drops or kits, add one temporary checklist line: “Does the new item actually serve this prompt?” New lashes are optional, not mandatory. Codes remain unrelated to quality—Codes Hub is still empty of active publics as of November 2026.
Keep it ethical
This checklist will not help you auto-vote or steal looks via scripts. Those paths risk bans and are unverified for this game—see Scripts. Improvement here is legitimate craft under creator dnatellaversace’s systems.
Pin this page with the Theme Idea Board, warm up in Free Play, then let anonymous votes judge a finished story. For orientation, the Wiki Hub maps every section of the site.
Frequently Asked Questions
Quick answers to the most common MAKEUP ALL STARS questions.
When during the round should I run the checklist?
In the final third of the timer, after hair and lashes are on, while you still have seconds for micro-fixes.
What if I never have time left for a checklist?
Practice with a clock in Free Play and simplify your default eye. Pacing is a skill, not just artistry.
Which checklist item costs players the most wins?
Theme mismatch and unfinished hair/lash harmony are the most common podium killers.
Should I use the extended checklist live?
No. Save the extended Free Play review for after sessions; live rounds need the 60-second version.
Does the checklist change for avant-garde themes?
The questions stay the same, but “readability” means a clear concept, not softness. Hard edges can be intentional.
Can a checklist replace voting strategy?
It improves your submit quality. Still vote thoughtfully and study How to Win for lobby psychology.